The Best Low, Non-Kitten Heels for When Your Feet Realize They Are No Longer in Their 20s

Credit: The Office of Angela Scott

Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the web’s best products. If you purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. Our editorial team is independent and only endorses products we believe in.

We like

We don't like

When I was a teenager, nothing was more repellant than the kitten heel. Why would you settle for an inch when you could take a mile? I don’t know if it’s because I’m in my 30s or because the pandemic undid years of rigorous heels-training, but I can’t tolerate uncomfortable shoes like I once did. 

Though I’m committed to reintroducing heels to my everyday wardrobe, kitten heels will not make the cut. There’s something about their silhouette that feels matronly. The funny thing is, kitten heels were invented for adolescent girls but older women adopted them (because they were comfortable) and that’s the association that stuck. 

Sure, I could just get over myself and embrace matron life but I also feel like kitten heels are uncomfortable with minimal lift — so what’s the gain? I prefer a platform, wedge, or block heel any day of the week. We’ve put together a guide of our favorite chunky, sleek, summery, and sculptural low-heel heels (and not a kitten heel in sight) that will elevate your look without ever going above 2.5 inches.

The Office of Angela Scott

Miss Amélie Mary Jane

$650
$650
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: The Office of Angela Scott

These are the type of shoes that strangers stop to compliment you on the street — and that’s just what happened when I wore them to a magic show. The double strap and beautiful detailing is eye-catching and the cork midsole is cushion-y and comfortable from the very first wear. They clock in right in the mid-range of heel heights with a 2-inch lift that pairs perfectly with cropped pants or a midi-skirt.

We like

We don't like

Nordstrom

VINCE Margo Platform Sandal

$298
$298
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Nordstrom

These remind me of an updated (and elevated) version of the 2000s ubiquitous Steve Madden Slinkys that I will never not associate with my childhood best friend. No stretchy fabric here — 100% leather and a 2.38-inch heel.

We like

We don't like

ALTERRE

Agate Blue Slide + Grace Strap

$235
$235
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: ALTERRE

Who doesn’t love a 2-in-1 shoe? Remove the statement strap from this 1.5-inch heel and you’re left with an elegant mule.

We like

We don't like

REEF

Lofty Lux Hi

$81
$81
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: REEF

You won’t even feel like you’re wearing heels in this cushiony, 2.5 inch platform with a subtle square toe. The pastel colors will complement your cotton candy pedicure.

We like

We don't like

Sophia Webster

Chiara Block Sandal

$560
$560
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Sophia Webster

These 2.36 inch block heels are *almost* too pretty to wear. I saw a pair of these in the wild (at ATLA on Lafayette Street) and was immediately transported to a butterfly vivarium.

We like

We don't like

Quince

Italian Leather Lug Sole Loafer

$90
$90
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Quince

Does a lug sole loafer count as a low heel? It adds a full 1.5 inches to your height and that qualifies as a heel in my book!

We like

We don't like

Zappos

Dr. Scholl’s Original Too Slide Sandal

$130
$130
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Zappos

Yes, you will inevitably clunk the heavy, 1.375-inch, wooden platform against your ankle bone and your knees will buckle — but it’s worth it to look like you’re in the Pink Ladies.

We like

We don't like

Revolve

RAYE Ani Wedge

$168
$168
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Revolve

Clocking in at 2.5 inches, these are the wedges for feet exhibitionists. This clear lucite design will make you look like you’re walking on air.

We like

We don't like

Ancient Greek Sandals

Lithi Block Heel

$375
$375
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Ancient Greek Sandals

I’m a sucker for any unnecessary wrap around the shin (it’s so summery!) These 1.97-inch block heels make for perfect dancing-all-night, wedding guest shoes.

We like

We don't like

BRYR

Chonk Slide

$295
$295
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: BRYR

Platforms are dominating this list and for good reason — they’re one of the most comfortable iterations of high heels. With a 2.14 inch platform and layer of shock-absorbing rubber at the bottom, these clogs will give you a boost without slowing your stride.

We like

We don't like

Melissa

Possession Sandal

$99
$99
Code:
Copy Icon
Credit: Melissa

This 2.36-inch, heeled jelly is girlhood incarnate. It’ll make you want to chase after the ice cream man and have a water balloon fight.

We like

We don't like

Coupon:
Shop Now
At
The Office of Angela Scott
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Nordstrom
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
REEF
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Sophia Webster
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Revolve
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Ancient Greek Sandals
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
BRYR
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Melissa
The Office of Angela Scott
$650
$650
Code:
Copy Icon
REEF
$81
$81
Code:
Copy Icon
Sophia Webster
$560
$560
Code:
Copy Icon
Revolve
$168
$168
Code:
Copy Icon
Ancient Greek Sandals
$375
$375
Code:
Copy Icon
BRYR
$295
$295
Code:
Copy Icon
Melissa
$99
$99
Code:
Copy Icon
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.

A little lift goes a long way and these not-too-high heels will provide the bump you need. And even if a kitten heel reminds you of Mad Men secretaries, the lesson we should internalize is that what seems so indisputably sophisticated today will appear silly when we look back — and that’s a good thing! Embrace changing your style and evolving. In JB’s immortal words: never say never.

Shop The Edit

Coupon:
Shop Now
At
The Office of Angela Scott
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Nordstrom
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
REEF
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Sophia Webster
Coupon:
Coupon:
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Revolve
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Ancient Greek Sandals
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
BRYR
Coupon:
Shop Now
At
Melissa

Additional Reading

No items found.