Our team is dedicated to finding and telling you more about the web’s best products. If you purchase through our links, we may receive a commission. Our editorial team is independent and only endorses products we believe in.
We’ll soon be in the part of the season when it’s a comfort (not fashion) choice to double back for the warm-weather headgear you almost left home without. If your checklist usually consists of “gloves, scarf, hat,” it can easily be transformed into “gloves, scarf, earmuffs” when hat hair is simply not an option. Earmuffs keep chilly winds at bay without creating a static-fest when you remove them.
But if you’re partial to a reliable winter beanie, we have options for you as well. We’ve picked out several hats that range from straightforward to more jazzed up (and even one cloche). Whether you’re team hat or team earmuff, as the sun sets earlier and temperatures drop, these picks will help you stay toasty with cashmere, be-pearled, and shearling accessories.
We like
We don't like
The Notice-Me Earmuff
If you tire of winter neutrals quickly, consider these very un-neutral earmuffs from Nooki Design. The bright ping color (“Fondant”) calls to holiday sugarplums and gumdrops, and will definitely attract compliments. I love how these muffs are extra fluffy from the muffs to the band that will keep your ears from freezing. If you’re on the fence about earmuffs, the super soft faux fur will win you over and ensure these become a staple in your winter wardrobe.
We like
We don't like
The Maximalist Earmuff
All my Blair Waldorf-loving, classic fashion ladies rejoice! The cult favorite brand channels bold femininity that has found popularity with women and children alike. These earmuffs feature voluminous faux fur and copious faux pearls, which have warmth and fashion competing for a reigning position. These are undoubtedly a maximalist choice that will zhuzh up even the most basic cold-weather outfits.
We like
We don't like
The Ski Bunny Earmuff
Full-on faux fur isn’t everyone’s cup of tea: for a slightly fluffy look, try these Rudsak earmuffs that have a fur band and puffer-inpsired accents. Rudsak is a Canadian brand specializing in outerwear, so you know they’re experts when it comes to combatting the elements. The ski coat material keeps this pair of earmuffs on theme with a slimmer profile than the previous two products. But they’re no less cozy — the nylon outer is complemented with a soft plush lining so your ears will be met with luxurious softness.
We like
We don't like
The Quirky Earmuff
For a whimsical look in an classic tufted style, try these faux sherpa muffs that will have you praying for a cold front so you can make use of the shearling goodness. While we’re used to shearling as a lining for boots and jackets, the fleecy texture is perfect to keep your ears from getting icicles when you’re running winter errands.
We like
We don't like
The Must-Have Beanie
Jenni Kayne is the queen of quality basics. Her casually chic line includes cocoon cardigans, shearling sandals, and cotton tees that elevate the everyday, so it’s no surprise that her cashmere beanie is equally enviable. This piece is a part of the GLCO x Jenni Kayne collaboration. There’s a kid’s version and a men's version if you want to treat the whole family to a cashmere party.
We like
We don't like
The Last Beanie You’ll Buy
A beanie doesn’t have to look “bank-robber chic” if you choose wisely. Naadam is known for sustainable materials which promote ethical conditions for the animals and herders involved in the manufacturing process. The thoughtful design of this hat incorporates a fold over for two layers soft cashmere on your ears. Offered in every color of the rainbow and built to last for years to come, we think this might be the last beanie you ever buy.
We like
We don't like
The Trapper Hat
I love the look of bucket hats in the warmer months, but I don’t love the feeling when my ears are so cold they hurt. If you have similar reservations about wearing a bucket hat in the cold, this knit hat will keep you plenty toasty. It’s constructed from responsibly-sourced mohair to protect the welfare of goats and their environment. This style of hat is warmest when it has a fairly close fit so choose the size (XS/S or M/L) that’s snug but not tight.
We like
We don't like
The Go-Anywhere Hat
For those who love a good Audrey Hepburn silk scarf moment, this unique hat allows you to translate the look to colder weather. If Charade, isn’t quite what you’re going for, you can also channel your inner babushka (or Kay Thompson) as you tie this under your chin. Think of it as the ability to add a hood to any coat. The quilted fabric (100% nylon) is reversible so you can pick between Navy and Latte depending on your mood. If you're left with any doubt as to whether this is a hat or not, the KULE website spells it out plainly: “It’s a hat.“
We like
We don't like
The Hat No One Else Will Have
Manoogian’s textile creations span socks, sweaters, serapes, and shoes — all designed with incredible attention to detail. This chic balaclava hat style had its heyday in the mid 1800’s, and is now making a major comeback. The hand-loomed shape lies somewhere between helmet and hood-like and while it’s not as tight fitting as a beanie, it will definitely retain warmth. This artisanal creation is perfect for those who appreciate craftsmanship and eschew anything that feels mass-produced.