In partnership with Good Chop. Editor’s Note: We only select and work with partners that meet our quality standards, so you can rest assured we only endorse products we believe in.
We like
We don't like
Featured Product
Finding high-quality meat that’s sustainably sourced is much easier said than done. I love a juicy steak – especially as I’ve been focusing more on my protein intake lately – but finding an option I feel good about can be a total headache. After enough questionable grocery store options and expensive butcher trips, I decided to give a few meat delivery options a try. And, I figured I’d bring you along with me!
Here, I’m sharing my experiences with Good Chop, ButcherBox, and Omaha Steaks. Each promises to bring the best cuts straight to your door, but which one truly delivers on quality, value, and convenience? I put them to the test to find out. Without further ado…
Best Value
When it comes to value, Good Chop, ButcherBox, and Omaha Steaks each have their perks. Here’s how they stack up:
Good Chop: Good Chop’s Medium Box starts at $149 and includes up to 36 portions or 14 lbs of your choice. The Large Box (72 portions or 28 lbs) is $269, which averages out to about $3.74 per serving. Additionally, Good Chop offers XL plan that retails for $359 (up to 42 lbs) allowing you to get almost 20% extra savings compared to the Medium plan! Plus, if you use code TQE120E, you can enjoy $120 off your first four boxes.
ButcherBox: Most shoppers go for the $169 Custom Classic Box, which includes 9-14 lbs of meat. The brand’s Custom ‘Big Box’ is over $306. In terms of value, that means ButcherBox’s portions come out to over $5 per serving if you want the option to choose your proteins and cuts. A bit pricier, but still decent value.
Omaha Steaks: Omaha Steaks offers a wide variety of packages, but their Steak Lovers Favorites Box – which included 10 steaks and one seasoning – cost me $186. It was definitely the most expensive option, and the quantities I received were pretty small.
Winner: Good Chop (Get $120 off with code ‘TQE120E’)
Best Sourcing
For those who care about where their meat comes from, sourcing is key.
Good Chop: Good Chop exclusively sources their products from American farms and fisheries. They work with family farms and independent ranchers, and their seafood is wild-caught off U.S. coastlines. Best of all, their products are all-natural with no artificial ingredients. It’s a win for quality and sustainability.
ButcherBox: ButcherBox imports most of its beef from Australia, though all of their beef is 100% grass-fed and grass-finished. It’s good, but not quite as locally focused as some might prefer.
Omaha Steaks: Omaha Steaks sources their beef from the Midwest, primarily Nebraska, and emphasizes grain-feeding to achieve their signature flavor (it’s worth noting here that they don’t make any promises to be antibiotic-free). It’s a more traditional approach, but their sourcing isn’t super transparent – and honestly doesn’t seem to be a main selling point for the brand (it took me some searching to find this information on their website).
Winner: Good Chop
Best Selection and Customization
When it comes to variety and flexibility, who comes out on top?
Good Chop: Good Chop is all about customization. With over 80 different cuts of beef, pork, chicken, and seafood, you get to pick exactly what you want. Plus, if you need to skip a month or change your delivery date, they make it super easy. And with their 100% risk-free money-back guarantee, you really can’t go wrong.
ButcherBox: ButcherBox has a lower-cost option for $146, but you only get to choose the type of meat, not the specific cuts. Their customizable option costs $169. It’s a bit more restrictive but still offers some flexibility.
Omaha Steaks: Omaha Steaks offers a wide variety of cuts and packages, so much so that the experience is pretty overwhelming. They have a lot of different packages – some of which include options like Lasagna, Shepherd’s Pie, and Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo – which are probably convenient for families with big budgets, but too complicated for someone simply looking for the best meat at the best value (choosing a la carte options separate from the preset packages add up quickly here).
Winner: Good Chop
Convenience
Convenience is a huge factor for any subscription service. Here’s how they measure up:
Good Chop: Good Chop keeps it simple. Each box is delivered to your door on your schedule, and you can cancel anytime. Everything is vacuum-sealed and frozen at peak freshness, so you can stock your freezer and cook whenever you’re ready.
ButcherBox: ButcherBox offers similar flexibility in terms of delivery and cancellation, with professional packaging to keep everything fresh.
Omaha Steaks: Omaha Steaks also offers flexible delivery and cancellation, with everything vacuum-sealed and flash-frozen. They provide a variety of packaging options, including cooler bags and dry ice for optimal freshness.
Winner: Tie
Overall Winner: Good Chop
While all three meat delivery services offer great products and quality, Good Chop stands out for several reasons:
- It’s the most affordable of the three subscriptions, and if you use code ‘TQE120E’ you can get $120 off across your first four boxes.
- Good Chop sources exclusively from American farms and fisheries committed to quality and sustainability. Supporting local businesses and investing in the local economy is a big plus.
- Finally, Good Chop offers the best customization options, with over 80 different cuts of beef (both 100% grass-fed and grain-finished), chicken, pork, and seafood. It’s a no-brainer for those who want control over what they’re eating.
If you’re looking for high-quality American meat and seafood that you can pick, with easy delivery options and at an affordable price, then Good Chop is your best bet.
.jpg){kind=spacer}
